Last Updated on May 19, 2026 by Bruno Bianchi
Moving to Spain as an American? See Settleguru’s full U.S.-tax checklist for FBAR, FATCA, FEIE, and state exit.
A Medium article titled “Why 73% of American Expats Leave Spain Within 2 Years (The Data No One Talks About)” was widely shared across expat communities in recent weeks.
Planning your move to Spain?
Get the free step-by-step roadmap used by 10,000+ expats — covering visas, budget, housing, and the mistakes to avoid.
Start the Moving to Spain Hub →Written by Alex Carter and published on Medium, the article claims that nearly three-quarters of Americans who move to Spain return to the United States within two years, citing bureaucracy, costs, language barriers, social isolation, and career stagnation as the main reasons.
According to the author, the conclusion is based on interviews with relocation agencies, Americans who attempted residency, and analysis of visa and residency data. The article has since been deleted and reposted, which further fueled discussion and skepticism within expat circles.
When the article was shared in a large American expat community in Spain, it generated hundreds of comments and strong reactions from people living the experience firsthand.
Why American Expats Leave Spain: Skepticism About the Numbers
One of the most common reactions questioned the validity of the 73% figure itself.
Not sure which city is right for you?
Compare cost of living, weather, expat community size, and lifestyle across 13 Spanish cities in our free guide.
Explore Cities →Several commenters pointed out that Medium articles are not peer-reviewed, that the methodology was unclear, and that the sample size described did not represent the tens of thousands of Americans currently living in Spain.
Others noted that many people who move to Spain never intend to stay permanently. Students, digital nomads, short-term workers, and people “trying it out for a year or two” may inflate return statistics without reflecting failure.
A recurring point was that leaving Spain does not necessarily mean the move was a mistake.
Bureaucracy: Real Problem, Not a Spain-Only One
Many commenters agreed with the article on one thing: Spanish bureaucracy is be slow, confusing, and frustrating.
However, long-term expats pushed back on the idea that Spain is uniquely difficult. Several compared it favorably to Italy, Greece, Portugal, and even parts of the United States, arguing that bureaucracy is a reality of life almost everywhere.
A repeated suggestion from experienced residents was simple: use a gestor, accept that things take time, and stop expecting systems to work like they do in the US.
American Expats Leave Spain Over Cost of Living Expectations
The article’s claims about unexpected expenses and high healthcare costs also drew strong reactions.
Some agreed that Spain can be more expensive than expected, particularly in cities like Madrid or Barcelona, especially when income drops after relocation.
Others strongly disputed the figures cited, especially regarding healthcare. Multiple commenters shared that their private health insurance costs were far lower than what the article described, even for people over 50.
The broader consensus was that financial stress usually comes from poor planning, not from Spain being inherently unaffordable.
Language and Integration: The Most Agreed-Upon Point
If there was one area where the community showed broad agreement, it was language.
Many commenters said that Americans who do not learn Spanish struggle significantly — not just with paperwork, but socially and emotionally. Several noted that some Americans expect to live comfortably in Spain while remaining in an English-speaking bubble, and that this expectation often leads to frustration and isolation.
At the same time, others emphasized that integration takes time and effort, and that returning home is not a failure if someone realizes the lifestyle is not for them.
Social Life, Identity, and the “Holiday Illusion”
A recurring theme in the discussion was the idea of “holiday thinking.”
Many commenters observed that people fall in love with Spain while on vacation and assume daily life will feel the same. Once routines, responsibilities, work, and bureaucracy set in, the shine wears off.
Several long-term expats emphasized that Spain is “just a place,” and that moving does not automatically fix dissatisfaction with life. Community, adaptability, and mindset were repeatedly cited as more important than location.
So Why Do Some Stay—and Thrive?
Across hundreds of comments, a clear pattern emerged about who tends to succeed long term:
- People who learn Spanish
- People with realistic expectations
- People who plan financially beyond the bare minimum
- People who accept cultural differences instead of fighting them
- People who build community, local or expat or both
Many commenters shared that their first one or two years were difficult, but ultimately worth it.
Planning your move to Spain? Check out our complete Moving to Spain guide, learn about the Non-Lucrative Visa, explore the cost of living in Spain, and discover your Digital Nomad Visa options.
Why American Expats Leave Spain: Final Takeaway
The reaction from the American expat community in Spain suggests that the question isn’t really “Why do 73% leave?”
It’s why some people come unprepared, and why others adapt.
While the Medium article struck a nerve and raised valid points about expectations, its numbers and framing were widely challenged by people living in Spain long-term. What the discussion ultimately revealed is that moving to Spain is neither a guaranteed dream nor an inevitable failure — it is a complex life change that rewards preparation, flexibility, and patience.
This article reflects personal opinions and experiences shared by Spainguru community members and is general information only. It is not legal, financial, or immigration advice.
Get your free step-by-step Spain move plan
10 emails over 2 weeks covering visas, budget, housing & the mistakes to avoid.
Join 10,000+ expats who used this roadmap.
100% free · No credit card · Unsubscribe anytime
