Question
Anyone dissuaded from pursuing citizenship due to potentially higher Spain Tax? As far as I know, due to the tax treaty betweeen the USA and Spain, I won’t (shouldn’t?) be taxed on a government pension while as a resident. But that could (will?) conceivably change if I were to become a Spanish citizen?
Answers
These are the answers of Spainguru’s Facebook group members:
“You are correct. Under the US/Spain tax treaty, pensions that come from government service (like a federal or state government pension) are not taxable by Spain, so long as you are not a Spanish citizen. They can be used to determine your tax bracket, though.”
“Once you become a Spanish citizen, your pension becomes taxable by Spain, changing your tax situation considerably. The good news is, if your pension becomes taxable in Spain, your US tax liability might decrease or disappear due to the tax treaty, which prevents double taxation.”
“The key is how much other income you have. If your only income is your federal retirement, then it all becomes taxable by Spain once you become a Spanish citizen. If you have other investments or income, it gets complicated.”
“If you become a Spanish citizen, you start getting taxed on your federal/state pension. But, you also won’t have to pay Uncle Sam anymore, so the amount it goes up probably won’t be as bad as you’re fearing; and you’ll now be entitled to Spanish healthcare for free, the full discounts on prescription meds, etc.”
Conclusion
Becoming a Spanish citizen indeed changes the tax implications on government pensions from the US, shifting the tax liability from the US to Spain due to changes in fiscal residency and citizenship status.
While this may increase tax liability in Spain, it reduces US tax obligations, balancing the financial impact. Additionally, the benefits of Spanish citizenship, such as access to healthcare and other social services, might offset the increased tax costs for many individuals considering this move.
It’s essential to consult with a tax professional familiar with both US and Spanish tax laws to fully understand and plan for these changes.
