Question
Spain Vs France: Whose bureaucracy is worse France’s or Spain’s? I’m trying to decide which would be an easier ‘move’, which is a big consideration for us.
Answers
These are the answers of Spainguru’s Facebook group members:
“Spain is worse.”
“But the people are so much nicer!”
“Both true.”
“Yeah the people are nicer but the bureaucracy is horrible. It’s the one thing my Spanish grandma used to complain about when I was younger and she was 100% correct.”
“France is worse, and they’re nasty about having to deal with the public, as a general rule. Spain is crazy, too, but they are so much more polite, respectful and helpful.”
“Spain has more bureaucracy and more relaxing lifestyle and great weather, but France is an easier visa, taxes, less bureaucracy, and in my opinion, the food and wine are better.”
“Taxes are not lower in France.”
“It depends on each person’s situation. Income tax is generally lower in France. Wealth tax is lower in France too, but if you’re not working or retired, France may be worse because they tax Social Security.”
“Get a facilitator in whichever country you choose to walk you through the lunacy. It’s worth it.”
“Facilitators help you with visa application, renewals, getting a driver’s license, registering with the government, etc. They save time and reduce stress, especially if you don’t speak the language.”
“France is about 30% more expensive than Spain. Bureaucracy has improved but the healthcare system is faltering. Still, you won’t go bankrupt over medical bills.”
“France is harder I hear.”
“France doesn’t tax Roths, IRAs or Social Security. Spain does.”
“Spain taxes Roth IRAs and HSAs. It doesn’t recognize post-tax accounts like the US does.”
“France taxes pensions differently depending on the type—some are exempt under the US-France tax treaty.”
“Spain is better by far.”
“France for sure… Spain is relaxed compared to the hoops they make you jump through in France.”
“I’ve lived in both and France has 100% less bureaucracy hands down! It’s like night and day!”
“Spain without a doubt!”
“Spain rules to retire.”
“Spain. French are more organized.”
“France’s is easier.”
“Spain is even worse than Mexico. It’s absolutely a PITA.”
“Coming to Spain and getting settled was easy for us. Visa came in 21 days. Renewal took a day. Picked up 2-year NLV 30 days later.”
“Spain’s bureaucracy is bad, but there are no French people. It’s better.”
“Spain has a process for everything. Once you get the hang of it, it’s easy. Plus people help.”
“Spain. French bureaucracy is more structured. Spain is more chaotic, but warmer.”
“Prepare yourself mentally. Immigration is never easy.”
Conclusion
The comparison between Spain Vs France when it comes to bureaucracy and ease of moving varies depending on each person’s priorities and experiences.
Key takeaways:
- Bureaucracy: France is generally seen as more structured but sometimes harsher in tone, while Spain may have more chaotic systems but friendlier people. Some say France is more efficient; others say Spain is easier to navigate once you’re familiar with the process.
- Facilitators: In both countries, hiring a local facilitator or gestor can drastically ease the process, especially for language barriers or understanding documentation requirements.
- Cost of Living: Spain is consistently noted as more affordable, up to 30% cheaper in overall expenses compared to France.
- Taxation: France might offer better treatment of pensions and retirement accounts like Roth IRAs and Social Security, while Spain is more aggressive in taxing global income.
- Lifestyle Fit: While bureaucracy matters, many respondents suggest choosing the country that aligns best with your lifestyle, language skills, and personal goals.
Ultimately, when deciding between Spain Vs France, bureaucracy is one factor, but it’s clear that both systems can be managed with patience, planning, and the right support.
Here’s a comparison Table between Spain Vs France
| Aspect | Spain | France |
|---|---|---|
| Bureaucracy | More relaxed but often inefficient. Long delays and vague processes are common. | More structured and organized, though sometimes perceived as stricter. |
| Immigration Process | Can be slow and frustrating without a facilitator. Appointments may be hard to book. | Generally more straightforward, especially for retirees. Language requirements apply. |
| Healthcare | Affordable and accessible. Mixed reviews on public care. Private insurance common. | Highly rated public healthcare. Costs low even without insurance. Better rural access may vary. |
| Cost of Living | Lower overall, including rent, groceries, and dining. | Higher living costs, particularly in urban areas like Paris. |
| Language Requirements | Speaking Spanish helps but not always required for residency. More leniency for tourists. | Strict language proficiency required for long-term residence and citizenship. |
| Taxes | Higher for residents; Spain taxes worldwide income, including Roth IRAs and Social Security. | Generally lower income tax rates; US pensions and Roth IRAs may not be taxed. |
| Lifestyle | Relaxed, friendly, community-oriented. Great weather and slower pace. | Culturally rich with world-class food and wine. More formal lifestyle in cities. |
| Wine & Food | Great wine at very affordable prices. Strong local food culture. | Globally acclaimed cuisine and wine. More expensive overall. |
